Game controllers, ranked by critic score
Game controllers for consoles, PCs and phones, judged on feel, latency, battery life and build quality.
Of the 3 game controllers we score so far, the highest-rated by professional reviewers is the GameSir G8+: critic score 88 out of 100 from 4 reviews, 3 of them positive. Most common complaint: software and app.
Image: GameSir4 professional reviewers tested the GameSir G8+, and 3 recommend it. Most common complaint: software and app.
The catch: It is bulky, with no headphone jack or passthrough charging.
Early score: only 4 professional reviews so far. Expect it to move as more reviews come in.
We earn a commission if you buy through these links. It never changes a score.
Not the GameSir G8+? Pick by situation
How do they compare?
| Product | Score | Reviews | Agreement | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| GameSir G8+ | 88 | 4 (early) | Medium | Top pick, narrowly |
| Nintendo Switch 2 Pro Controller | 85 | 4 (early) | Medium | Best Switch 2 controller |
| Valve Steam Controller | 81 | 4 (early) | Medium | Best for Steam gaming |
Common questions
Which controller do critics rate highest?
Of the 3 we score, the GameSir G8+, with a critic score of 88 from 4 professional reviews. Most common complaint: software and app.
GameSir G8+ vs Nintendo Switch 2 Pro Controller: which is better?
Critics score the GameSir G8+ 88 and the Nintendo Switch 2 Pro Controller 85. We list the Nintendo Switch 2 Pro Controller under “Best Switch 2 controller”. Its main drawback: it is expensive, and the sticks are not Hall effect and may drift.