CNET85est.
Named the best overall comforter from the reviewer's testing, who has slept under it nightly for about a year.
Buffy Cloud Comforter
4 expert reviewsChecked 1 Nov 2026
Quick answer
The Buffy Cloud Comforter has a critic score of 84 out of 100 from 4 professional reviews, including CNET, Business Insider and Sleep Foundation. 4 of 4 recommend it, and scores range from 83 (Sleep Foundation) to 85 (CNET). 0 of the scores are printed by the outlets and 4 are our estimates from the review text. Most praised: cooling (4 of 4); comfort (3 of 4). It ranks #2 of the 2 comforters we score.
Reviews checked 1 Nov 2026
Photo coming
Best for: Best eco-friendly pick
Our verdict
4 professional reviewers tested the Buffy Cloud Comforter, and 4 recommend it. Most praised: cooling and comfort.
The catch: Hard to wash, and it runs warm for some sleepers.
Critic agreement: Medium
Scores run from 83 to 850 printed scores, 4 estimated
Early score: only 4 professional reviews so far. Expect it to move as more reviews come in.
4 of these 4 outlets print no score. We estimated theirs from the review text and corrected for the known tendency of estimates to run high.
Check price at Amazon
We earn a commission if you buy through this link. It never changes a score.
What do critics say about the Buffy Cloud Comforter?
Business Insider85est.
The reviewer finds the Cloud soft, fluffy and surprisingly good at regulating temperature, and sees it as affordable and sustainable.
Sleep Foundation83est.
Named the most comfortable pick in a down-alternative roundup, with testers liking its mix of coziness and cooling.
Consumer Reports83est.
Recommended for hot sleepers because its layered fill avoids clumping and keeps temperature even, and a staffer called it extremely cuddly.
Scores are converted to 0–100. "est." means the outlet gave no number, so we estimated one from its verdict. How we score
What critics praise most
Cooling4 of 4
Comfort3 of 4
What critics dislike most
No clear pattern.
Alternatives
Not sure about the Buffy Cloud Comforter?
Common questions
Is the Buffy Cloud Comforter worth it?
Most critics think so: 4 of 4 recommend it. Hard to wash, and it runs warm for some sleepers.
Do critics agree about the Buffy Cloud Comforter?
Agreement is medium: scores range from 83 (Sleep Foundation) to 85 (CNET), a spread of 2 points across 4 reviews. Most reviewers land close together, with some outliers.
What is the best alternative to the Buffy Cloud Comforter?
The Brooklinen All-Season Down Comforter (critic score 87), best overall.