Mattress Clarity94
A great pick for hot sleepers who like a comforter, with breathable cotton and good airflow.
Brooklinen All-Season Down Comforter
6 expert reviewsChecked 1 Nov 2026
Quick answer
The Brooklinen All-Season Down Comforter has a critic score of 87 out of 100 from 6 professional reviews, including Mattress Clarity, Homes and Gardens and House Beautiful. 6 of 6 recommend it, and scores range from 83 (Tom's Guide) to 94 (Mattress Clarity). 1 of the scores are printed by the outlets and 5 are our estimates from the review text. Most praised: cooling (3 of 6); build quality (3 of 6). Most common complaints: runs hot (3 of 6); price (3 of 6). It ranks #1 of the 2 comforters we score.
Reviews checked 1 Nov 2026
Photo coming
Best for: Best overall
Our verdict
6 professional reviewers tested the Brooklinen All-Season Down Comforter, and 6 recommend it. Most praised: cooling and build quality. Most common complaint: runs hot.
The catch: Pricey, and care is limited to spot or dry cleaning.
Critic agreement: High
Scores run from 83 to 941 printed scores, 5 estimated
5 of these 6 outlets print no score. We estimated theirs from the review text and corrected for the known tendency of estimates to run high.
Check price at Amazon
We earn a commission if you buy through this link. It never changes a score.
What do critics say about the Brooklinen All-Season Down Comforter?
Homes and Gardens89est.
Recommended for almost anyone: light, fluffy and soft with ethical down.
House Beautiful85est.
Picked as best overall down comforter, with editors saying it holds up for years and is a favorite in the all-season weight.
Sleep Foundation85est.
Chosen as best overall down comforter for year-round use thanks to breathable cotton, three weights and a long trial.
Business Insider85est.
Called the best comforter the outlet has tested, still perfect after three years of nightly use.
Tom's Guide83est.
A cozy, well-made, premium comforter that looks great, though it traps heat on warm nights and is spot or dry clean only.
Scores are converted to 0–100. "est." means the outlet gave no number, so we estimated one from its verdict. How we score
What critics praise most
Cooling3 of 6
Build quality3 of 6
What critics dislike most
Runs hot3 of 6
Price3 of 6
Alternatives
Not sure about the Brooklinen All-Season Down Comforter?
Common questions
Is the Brooklinen All-Season Down Comforter worth it?
Most critics think so: 6 of 6 recommend it. Pricey, and care is limited to spot or dry cleaning.
Do critics agree about the Brooklinen All-Season Down Comforter?
Agreement is high: scores range from 83 (Tom's Guide) to 94 (Mattress Clarity), a spread of 11 points across 6 reviews. Reviewers broadly agree.
What do critics dislike about the Brooklinen All-Season Down Comforter?
Runs hot (3 of 6 reviews), Price (3 of 6 reviews).
What is the best alternative to the Brooklinen All-Season Down Comforter?
The Buffy Cloud Comforter (critic score 84), best eco-friendly pick.